So far, however, booksellers say, none of these books have lived up to their industry buzz, and some publishers and book industry watchers question whether "lad lit," as the genre has come to be called, will ever have a natural readership.
—Kate Zernike, "Oh, to Write A 'Bridget Jones' For Men," The New York Times, February 22, 2004

The only offshoot that's flopping, Hensley said, is "lad lit," or books about men in their 20s searching for Ms. Right, like Jim Keeble's trade paperback original, Men and Other Mammals (Hyperion, May). "Unless you're Nick Hornby, it's a small sliver of an audience," she said.
—Natalie Danford, "The Chick Lit Question," Publisher's Weekly, October 20, 2003

Fifteen years ago, versions of these boys' lives might well have appeared in print, but they would probably have been apprentice novels, featuring similar, but more impressive young men, with made-up names and sexier girlfriends. Ten years ago, they might have used travel writing as the pretext for some disarming revelations about gamily male behaviour. Today's adventurers prefer to let their fingers do the walking, staying at home and burrowing into the past. The result is what publishers celebrate as 'the new non-fiction', or what Bill Buford, who, as editor of Granta, started this vogue for blokeish narrative, chooses to call 'lad literature'.
—Catherine Bennett, "True confessions," The Guardian, July 7, 1995